Incompetence, apathy, or political choice?
Submitted by Larry Cannell on Sat, 09/10/2005 - 15:00.
Imagine you are the most powerful person in the world; the President of The United States. You have enormous and powerful resources at your disposal. A superpower military can be mobilized at your command.
Then you are briefed on the worst hurricane in recent history heading towards New Orleans, which is known to be a disaster waiting to happen. You don't just read this in the newspaper, you are personally briefed by the federal agency that tracks these things.
It is predicted that many Americans will die, the area will be devastated for years, and there is a strong liklihood of catastrophic flooding, the nightmare scenario everyone has feared.
What does W do? He delegates it, to Chertoff and Brown.
Do you think W's response would have been different if the hurricane was heading towards Texas, Maine, Washington DC or Florida?
How could this happen? I see three possible scenarios:
But, we need to find out how the federal government could have bungled such an important job. This isn't just another political scandal that will end when someone is fired. This screw-up cost thousands of lives and is one reason why we have the impeachment process.
Update: Best mainstream media observation made regarding W's response:
Then you are briefed on the worst hurricane in recent history heading towards New Orleans, which is known to be a disaster waiting to happen. You don't just read this in the newspaper, you are personally briefed by the federal agency that tracks these things.
It is predicted that many Americans will die, the area will be devastated for years, and there is a strong liklihood of catastrophic flooding, the nightmare scenario everyone has feared.
What does W do? He delegates it, to Chertoff and Brown.
Do you think W's response would have been different if the hurricane was heading towards Texas, Maine, Washington DC or Florida?
How could this happen? I see three possible scenarios:
- Incompetence (or maybe, dereliction of duty).
- Apathy towards impoverished people and people of color. How can anyone argue with Kayne West's statements?
- An educated choice to do nothing, perhaps for political gain.
But, we need to find out how the federal government could have bungled such an important job. This isn't just another political scandal that will end when someone is fired. This screw-up cost thousands of lives and is one reason why we have the impeachment process.
Update: Best mainstream media observation made regarding W's response:
How this could be—how the president of the United States could have even less "situational awareness," as they say in the military, than the average American about the worst natural disaster in a century—is one of the more perplexing and troubling chapters in a story that, despite moments of heroism and acts of great generosity, ranks as a national disgrace.
Evan Thomas on MSNBC.Com
Evan Thomas on MSNBC.Com
Larry Cannell's blog | 1852 reads »